I will be attending the SBL Annual Meeting in Chicago this weekend. It's my first SBL conference and I'm a little excited :)
Wednesday, November 14, 2012
Sunday, June 3, 2012
On the Burden (or Onus) of Proof
ETA: see below.
Some interesting thoughts on the so-called "onus [or burden] of proof" are out on the web right now, and I wanted to make a few comments, if I may:
I agree the "burden of proof" concept is maybe overstated in humanistic disciplines like religious studies. I'd also agree that in areas without a consensus position, the burden is indeed simply on the person trying to make one case or another. Having said that, I think there are meaningful ways in which a "burden of proof" can be employed.
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Euangelion Kata Markon on Secret Mark
Michael Kok has devoted a series at his blog to Secret Mark. I'm quite interested to see what will result.
Sunday, March 18, 2012
The HSH in the Context of Johannine Studies
I thought I'd finally put this post up--I wrote it last fall as part of my ongoing exploration of the role that the Signs Gospel plays in the Hyper-Synoptic Hypothesis, but got busy with other things and it's been sitting for a while. But I'd like to explain how the Hyper-Synoptic Hypothesis relates to the study of the Gospel of John, so I've revised this post and here it is.
The HSH, at least with regards to the role of the Signs Gospel, does fit into a previously-established tradition of Johannine scholarship, though this tradition is perhaps not a mainstream one. The Signs hypothesis in general (that is, that there was a source for the Gospel of John that contained a sequence of symbolic miracles called "signs") is not universally accepted, and indeed one might argue that it has never been mainstream opinion. I wanted to explain that I am aware of this, but that there is nevertheless an ongoing thread in Johannine studies that does assume the existence of a Signs document (of some sort or other), even one that relates to the Gospels of Mark and John in the way that I claim it does.
I'll present this as a more-or-less chronological study of the concept of a Signs source in the history of New Testament criticism.
The HSH, at least with regards to the role of the Signs Gospel, does fit into a previously-established tradition of Johannine scholarship, though this tradition is perhaps not a mainstream one. The Signs hypothesis in general (that is, that there was a source for the Gospel of John that contained a sequence of symbolic miracles called "signs") is not universally accepted, and indeed one might argue that it has never been mainstream opinion. I wanted to explain that I am aware of this, but that there is nevertheless an ongoing thread in Johannine studies that does assume the existence of a Signs document (of some sort or other), even one that relates to the Gospels of Mark and John in the way that I claim it does.
I'll present this as a more-or-less chronological study of the concept of a Signs source in the history of New Testament criticism.
A Brief History of Scholarship on the Relation of GJohn to the Synoptics
Sunday, February 19, 2012
Is This Part of the Infamous 1st Century Papyrus of GMk?
This was posted today on someone's Facebook profile (?!).
So far all I can say of it is that it looks a bit odd in several ways.
I'm not really one to make much of these things; just thought it was of interest.
No doubt Brill will have done their due diligence when they eventually publish the official report.
Sunday, October 2, 2011
Quick Thoughts on a New Fragment of GMK
Just wanted to say one or two things about P.Oxy. 5072:
http://www.ox.ac.uk/media/news_stories/2011/110726.html
Tony Burke has a bit more here:
http://www.tonyburke.ca/apocryphicity/2011/09/19/new-unknown-gospel-from-oxyrhynchus/
Roger Viklund has a couple of pieces here (if you use Chrome, you can tell it to translate with a single click):
http://rogerviklund.wordpress.com/2011/09/20/ett-nytt-evangelium-patraffat/
http://rogerviklund.wordpress.com/2011/09/29/overlaps-between-secret-mark-the-raising-of-lazarus-in-john-and-the-gerasene-swine-episode-in-mark/
My own thoughts:
http://www.ox.ac.uk/media/news_stories/2011/110726.html
Tony Burke has a bit more here:
http://www.tonyburke.ca/apocryphicity/2011/09/19/new-unknown-gospel-from-oxyrhynchus/
Roger Viklund has a couple of pieces here (if you use Chrome, you can tell it to translate with a single click):
http://rogerviklund.wordpress.com/2011/09/20/ett-nytt-evangelium-patraffat/
http://rogerviklund.wordpress.com/2011/09/29/overlaps-between-secret-mark-the-raising-of-lazarus-in-john-and-the-gerasene-swine-episode-in-mark/
My own thoughts:
Sunday, September 11, 2011
Suggestion Box (a publishing question)
What are the best journals in which to publish on patristics?
From what I can tell they include:
Catholic Biblical Quarterly
possibly Novum Testamentum
probably Journal for the Study of the New Testament
Journal of Early Christian Studies
Vigiliae Christianae
maybe also Journal of Greco-Roman Christianity and Judaism (Are they still publishing? They have only one paper listed for 2011 on their website.)
In some cases Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus could be appropriate.
Have I covered everything? Which would you try to publish in first? Keep in mind that I am a first-time author, unaffiliated with a graduate proram, a religious or classical studies department, or any religious institution at all.
From what I can tell they include:
Catholic Biblical Quarterly
possibly Novum Testamentum
probably Journal for the Study of the New Testament
Journal of Early Christian Studies
Vigiliae Christianae
maybe also Journal of Greco-Roman Christianity and Judaism (Are they still publishing? They have only one paper listed for 2011 on their website.)
In some cases Journal for the Study of the Historical Jesus could be appropriate.
Have I covered everything? Which would you try to publish in first? Keep in mind that I am a first-time author, unaffiliated with a graduate proram, a religious or classical studies department, or any religious institution at all.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
