Sadly, I probably won't be able to attend, due to constraints of time and finances, but the second York University Christian Apocrypha Symposium will take place next month, and I encourage anyone reading this to attend. The first one was terrifically engaging and of very high quality, and produced a stellar proceedings, and this year's efforts look sure to be the equal of the first.
Were I to attend, I'd probably single out the following events:
Thursday, September 19, 2013
Saturday, June 15, 2013
Viklund and Paananen in Vigiliae Christianae
I've been very busy for the past week or so, and I managed to miss this, but I was surprised and rather pleased to see Roger Viklund, with Timo Paananen, publish his findings in VC on the mistaken analysis of the Mar Saba handwriting that Carlson undertakes in The Gospel Hoax. Congrats to Roger and Timo.
Viklund's analysis now enters the published, peer-reviewed literature. This is great news for defenders of Smith's honesty.
And I absolutely must add (and IMHO this is a little ground-breaking) that this seems to establish a precedent for scholarly publication of findings originally published on the web. Viklund originally posted these findings on his blog back in late 2009. We now see those findings, or at least a succinct summary of them, published in a scholarly setting.
It would seem, then, that blog material can in fact be re-presented. What it takes to pass peer-review, I guess, is a meaningful revision of that material. The fact that we now have an effective standard for this seems like kind of a big deal to me. I think everyone in the discipline should be paying attention to this--I can't think of another example of this type of blog-to-journal publication (or a better one, at any rate) in the field of biblical studies. However, I would be happy to be proven wrong and pointed to other examples.
Viklund's analysis now enters the published, peer-reviewed literature. This is great news for defenders of Smith's honesty.
And I absolutely must add (and IMHO this is a little ground-breaking) that this seems to establish a precedent for scholarly publication of findings originally published on the web. Viklund originally posted these findings on his blog back in late 2009. We now see those findings, or at least a succinct summary of them, published in a scholarly setting.
It would seem, then, that blog material can in fact be re-presented. What it takes to pass peer-review, I guess, is a meaningful revision of that material. The fact that we now have an effective standard for this seems like kind of a big deal to me. I think everyone in the discipline should be paying attention to this--I can't think of another example of this type of blog-to-journal publication (or a better one, at any rate) in the field of biblical studies. However, I would be happy to be proven wrong and pointed to other examples.
Sunday, December 2, 2012
Preliminaries, and a new diagram
I have little time this week, unfortunately, to devote the attention I need to the question of the Gospel of Thomas and the Synoptics (though I have already drafted some comments), but I did have time to put together a new HSH diagram. Here it is:
Thursday, November 29, 2012
On Thomas and the Gospels
The session on Thomas Among the Gospels at the 2012 SBL Annual Meeting was lively and informative, or at least I found it so. It has also spurred new thinking on my part about one corner of the Hyper-Synoptic Hypothesis, so it was even more productive than I expected.
Sunday, November 25, 2012
Some Hurried Words on SBL
Haven't had much time to blog amidst travel and socializing all week, so these notes I've jotted down are the best I can provide.
Saturday, November 24, 2012
Brief Post on the Forthcoming Secret Mark Book
Travel and socializing has taken up most of my time this week, but I hope to have some more about SBL Chicago soon, especially on the Gospel of Thomas session (which merits a post of its own). In the meantime, I would be remiss if I did not mention the forthcoming volume on the York University Christian Apocrypha Symposium of last year, Ancient Gospel or Modern Forgery? with Tony Burke as editor:
http://www.tonyburke.ca/apocryphicity/2012/11/16/secret-gospel-of-mark-in-debate/
Please do buy it when it comes out! It will be a very informative volume.
http://www.tonyburke.ca/apocryphicity/2012/11/16/secret-gospel-of-mark-in-debate/
Please do buy it when it comes out! It will be a very informative volume.
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Gathercole on GTh
I opened Gathercole's The Composition of the Gospel of Thomas expecting a formidable challenge to the Hyper-Synoptic Hypothesis. Instead, I discovered that Gathercole's thesis and the HSH hardly speak to each other at all. And where they do, they actually agree.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
